Not signed in (Sign In)

Vanilla 1.0.1 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.

    • CommentAuthornsidestrate
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006 edited
     
    Rock on, my mafioso friends.
  1.  
    If you enter a topic with a category of "mafia" only you guys will be able to see it, should you need to start a new topic. I don't think it much matters, because we never really used this thing anyhow.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I am in. Here's my plan....


    One of us, not the Don, claims during the night to be the Detective. He asks for protection from the Doctor each night. In return he can safely tell the group the results of his investigation each day.

    The first day we finger a random as an innocent. About day 2 or 3 we mix in fingering a mafia as an innocent. The only time our cover is blown is when we kill the detective by random walk, or the detective calls attention to himself, or we id so many non-mafias that people get suspicious.

    What say ye?
  2.  
    I think Darvon and McFoldem are the only ones here at the moment. I told Angel-fish, but I haven't reached irishiain yet.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I like the idea, but I think it may be a little early. Someone today figured the detective should stay hidden for 2-3 days.

    The small problem with the plan is why is the Mafia not taking out the detective?
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Angel-fish went out, she said she would be back later tonight.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    The mafia may not want to waste a shot if they think the doctor is protecting the dtective.

    I really want to try this before many others post in the night. We should post early in the "night" for best results.

    We should also see comments back before taking tonight's shot.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Do you think they will be posting in the night, I think they will wait until morning to post.

    I see your point about the Doctor.

    What do you think the real detective will do?
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    The real detective may post or just keep quiet until he finds a Mafia. Lynching whover ANYONE fingers as truth will be a lie-detector for all the psuedo-detectives.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I can hardly CONTAIN myself. I want to do this NOW.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Who should we kill?

    I say Suited. She can spy on nside.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Or pie.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Or maybe we shouldn't kill anyone who fingered mafioso in the first round, Less the rabble reverse engineer thier vote and kill us.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I guess we want to bring him out if we can. Although I think TheRiverkid is the Detective at the moment.

    Okay, so say you become the detective. You anounce it tonight. Say doctor protects before morning? We would we target someone other than Theriverkid in case he is the detective. That would definitly blow your cover.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    As far as who to kill, I was leaning toward TheRiverkid due to him fingering Angel-fish. It could be a shot in the dark pick or it could have been made with some Detective knowledge. But for your plan to work we need him. I would lean toward Cybrarian(doctor possiblity). Alot of the other flop there votes around with little conviction.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Also, we should vote for ourselves as long as it is under critical mass, so after a few days, the rabble can't reverse engineer our votes to see that who makes a group of 5 that doesnt' every nominate itself.

    I will vote to kill irishlain next day. But only if most are gathering on someone else.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    we shouldn't kill anyone who fingered one of us today.

    Me, and Angel were fingered by 5 I believe.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Pie
    TRK
    Suited
    Taz

    are off our list for tonite.

    If we nail SteveGriff and then someone else (not me) says that since the Mafia nailed Stefe, maybe his candidate Toom was mafia then they can lynch Toom.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I thought about voting for oursselves as well, in fact i told Angel-fish that if she got 7-8 votes I may vote for her which would really make me look good as an innocent. Not sure if i would or not but I gave it some thought.

    Cybrarian mentioned today that we as innocents aren't to just toss names out there, we would need a reason for voting for them.

    So who is on your list then, Ey, Cybrarian, Fumseck, cicerius, Damo_1, Malteg
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Darvon wrote:
    "If we nail SteveGriff and then someone else (not me) says that since the Mafia nailed Stefe, maybe his candidate Toom was mafia then they can lynch Toom."

    I like the way you think here.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    The Detective will have 2 names by Day 2. If it is TRK, then he random hit on Angel on Day 1. If he doesn't finger someone tommorrow then we may assume he struck out.

    I think Pie is the detective because he started with ME and then switched to Angel when TRK broke the ice. Detective gets Mafia at 1:4 odds, so it is extremely unlikely that he hit two mafia by random.

    Much easier to think that he hit Me and then jumped to Angel to get the heat off him.

    But more likely for our smart Pie is that he picked me by random, planning to jump on the Angel bandwagon, who he knew to be mafia, as soon as someone else broached it.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Darvon Wrote:
    " think Pie is the detective because he started with ME and then switched to Angel when TRK broke the ice. Detective gets Mafia at 1:4 odds, so it is extremely unlikely that he hit two mafia by random."

    Pie picked you because Suited did. Suited named you first.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    can you reach ian some way? can you aim him?
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Ian's MSN is offline.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Shall I go "Detective" now or wait till Angel and Ian come back?
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    The other thing is Pie did not hit Angel, he wavered and went with the others that had already hit on Angel.

    TheRiverkid is the one that hit on her. He never wavered off of her when everyone else flopped to Angel, and then to Nobody. His vote stayed on Angel. This could be due to him making a lucky guess, and then not being on the forum when all the swapping was going on.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    There is time, I do not want to rush it. They should definitely have a say in the matter.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Pie hit Angel in the #2 slot. Taz jumped on as #3. Kid broached Angel.

    Pie broached me. Suited jumped on.

    Pie or suited is Dtective????
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Take another look Darvon, Suited mentions you first. It isn't in bold but it is there.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    He even says he is going along with what Suited says
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006 edited
     
    I still stand by TRK is the detective.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Right.

    Suited broached me. Pie jumped on.

    Kid broached angel. Pie jumped. Taz jumped.

    As soon as someone kills a mafia, let's go after the early nominators as Detectives.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006 edited
     
    Why would TRK come out and say Angel-fish would be the better bet?
    Two people had already chosen you. If the TRK was NOT the detective would he not take stock in the the two people that picked Darvon and think that maybe one of them was the detective?

    Maybe I am over thinking.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    If the TRK was not the detective would henot take stock in the Darvon picks thinking that maybe they were the detective?


    NOPE. There were 11 non-detectives and nobody else jumped on.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Kid, Pie and Suited are our suspects.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I say we shoot Griff tonite and then hope someone else (not us) goes to Lynch Toom.

    Then if they lynch toom, we can hope the nominator is lynched as a mafia suspect.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Agree with your Detectives list, the order I would give is kid, suited, pie.
    We don't have a whole lot to go by yet.

    Who is the Doctor? any lines on him/her
  3.  
    I'm probably going to crash around 11:30 est. If Angel or irish register after I crash, they won't get access until morning.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    If KID is detective, and we wait until he nominates a 2nd mafia, then when we nuke him and everyone sees he is the Detective his old nominees (2) will be dead.

    If Pie is detective, and we wait until he nominates a 3rd mafie, then 3 of us will die.

    If suited, then 2.

    We will probably see the Detective as somone who DOESN"T nominate an innocent 2 days in a row. He either will be quiet or tricky.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I have to 2nd the Griff pick for the Cement shoes and one way ticket to the bottom of the river.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    The doctor has no more info than a rabble. What he has to do is try to figure the Detective before we do, with less info.

    We can only random walk him out. Unless he posts.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Ok thanks alot for the forum Nside?

    Suited doesn't have an account here does she?

    And do you talk in your sleep?
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I am a little concerned about being the first detective to post. It has Mafia written all over it.
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Nside,

    No problem.

    have a good nite....
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006 edited
     
    "I am a little concerned about being the first detective to post. It has Mafia written all over it."

    I think the 2nd to post does.

    But if the Real Detective does post 1st, what shall we do?
  4.  
    Suited can not read this message or any massage labelled as "mafia." I even signed in as her to double check that.

    I don't talk in my sleep. It is awkward because she wants to talk about the strategy and I won't discuss it with her. She is far too clever of a cross-examiner -- I had to adopt a no talking policy.

    By the way, what do you guys think about the strategy by the town to not lynch anyone?
    • CommentAuthordarvon
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    ian is ON the ITH forum.

    AIM him now please.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    I don't mind it, but maybe more becuase they had 2 of the mafia picked. It was looking like Angel was a goner before the No Lynching came up.
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Ian is on the way
    • CommentAuthorMcFoldem
    • CommentTimeApr 12th 2006
     
    Nside did you mean the strategy of allowing a non-kill, or the town's choice?